1
American Fence & Supply
🏆 #1 in Toledo
Ranked by Google ratings, review quality, and response time. Updated April 2026.
1630 Coining Dr, Toledo, OH 43612, USA, Toledo, OH
Why they ranked: Our top-ranked pick with an exceptional 5-star rating across 322 Google reviews.
5810 Southwyck Blvd, Toledo, OH 43614, USA, Toledo, OH
Why they ranked: A close runner-up with an exceptional 5-star rating across 56 Google reviews.
920 Illinois Ave, Maumee, OH 43537, USA, Toledo, OH
Why they ranked: Ranked #3 with an exceptional 5-star rating from 17 reviews.
5222 Tractor Rd, Toledo, OH 43612, USA, Toledo, OH
Why they ranked: Ranked #4 with an exceptional 5-star rating from 13 reviews.
5770 Lewis Ave, Temperance, MI 48182, USA, Toledo, OH
Why they ranked: Ranked #5 with an exceptional 5-star rating.
Pickard Rd, Temperance, MI 48182, USA, Toledo, OH
Why they ranked: Ranked #6 with an exceptional 4.9-star rating from 44 reviews.
5242 Tractor Rd, Toledo, OH 43612, USA, Toledo, OH
Why they ranked: Ranked #7 with an exceptional 4.9-star rating from 22 reviews.
5745 Navarre Ave, Oregon, OH 43616, USA, Toledo, OH
Why they ranked: Ranked #8 with an exceptional 4.8-star rating across 139 Google reviews.
5417 Alger Dr, Sylvania, OH 43560, USA, Toledo, OH
Why they ranked: Ranked #9 with an exceptional 4.8-star rating across 94 Google reviews.
E Manhattan Blvd, Toledo, OH 43611, USA, Toledo, OH
Why they ranked: Ranked #10 with an exceptional 4.8-star rating across 72 Google reviews.
Rating Score (50%) — Average star rating from Google customer reviews.
Review Volume (30%) — Number of Google reviews. More reviews = greater confidence.
Response Time (20%) — Faster response times earn higher rankings.
Only businesses with 3+ reviews are eligible. Rankings refresh every hour. Paid listings do not influence ranking order.
American Fence & Supply currently holds the top spot with a 5-star rating across 322 reviews.
No. Paid tiers get additional profile features, but ranking order is determined solely by ratings, reviews, and response time.
List your business and accumulate at least 3 Google reviews. Rankings are automatic and updated hourly.
Browse fence contractors by zip code or neighborhood in Toledo.
Browse by Zip Code